Act I
Fly to Your Heart (Part 1)
Fairies, Tinker Bell
The Elegant Captain Hook
Michael, John, Wendy
The Second Star to the Right (Part 1)
Wendy, Fairies
The Second Star to the Right (Part 2)
Wendy
You Can Fly (Part 1)
Peter, Michael, John, Wendy
You Can Fly/Fly to Your Heart (Part 2)
Tinker Bell, Fairies, Company
Yo Ho (A Pirate’s Life for Me)
Pirates
Never Smile at a Crocodile
Captain Hook, Pirates
You Can Fly (Reprise 1)
Michael, John, Wendy
Following the Leader
John, Michael, Lost Boys, Indians
Sunbeams and Sea (Part 1)
Mermaids
Sunbeams and Sea (Part 2)
Mermaids
What Makes the Brave Man Brave
Indians, Tiger Lily
Your Mother and Mine
Wendy, Lost Boys, Pirates
Walk the Plank
Captain Hook, Pirates
You Can Fly (Reprise 2)
Michael, John, Wendy
You Can Fly/Fly to Your Heart (Part 3)
Fairies, Tinker Bell, Peter, Company