Act I
- Prelude
- "Just Another Day" – Diana, Natalie, Gabe, Dan
- "Everything Else" – Natalie
- "Who's Crazy" / "My Psychopharmacologist and I" – Dan, Doctor Fine, Diana
- "Perfect for You" – Henry, Natalie
- "I Miss the Mountains" – Diana
- "It's Gonna Be Good" – Dan, Natalie, Henry, Diana
- "He's Not Here" – Dan
- "You Don't Know" – Diana
- "I Am the One" – Dan, Gabe, Diana
- "Superboy and the Invisible Girl" – Natalie, Diana, Gabe
- "I'm Alive" – Gabe
- "Make Up Your Mind" / "Catch Me I'm Falling" – Doctor Madden, Diana, Dan, Natalie, Gabe, Henry
- "I Dreamed a Dance" – Diana, Gabe
- "There's a World" – Gabe
- "I've Been" – Dan, Gabe
- "Didn't I See This Movie?" – Diana
- "A Light in the Dark" – Dan, Diana
There will be one, fifteen-minute intermission.
Act II
- "Wish I Were Here" – Diana, Natalie
- "Song of Forgetting" – Dan, Diana, Natalie
- "Hey #1" – Henry, Natalie
- "Seconds and Years" – Doctor Madden, Dan, Diana
- "Better Than Before" – Doctor Madden, Dan, Natalie, Diana
- "Aftershocks" – Gabe
- "Hey #2" – Henry, Natalie
- "You Don't Know" (Reprise) – Diana, Doctor Madden
- "How Could I Ever Forget?" – Diana, Dan
- "It's Gonna Be Good" (Reprise) – Dan, Diana
- "Why Stay?" / "A Promise" – Diana, Natalie, Dan, Henry
- "I'm Alive" (Reprise) – Gabe
- "The Break" – Diana
- "Make Up Your Mind" / "Catch Me I'm Falling" (Reprise) – Doctor Madden, Diana, Gabe
- "Maybe (Next to Normal)" – Diana, Natalie
- "Hey #3" / "Perfect for You" (Reprise) – Henry, Natalie
- "So Anyway" – Diana
- "I Am the One" (Reprise) – Dan, Gabe
- "Light" – Diana, Dan, Natalie, Gabe, Henry, Doctor Madden
