Act I
Happy All The Time
Santa (Hunter), All Elves (Addie, Priya, Madeline, Emily, Olivia, Vi, Lark & Alice), Buddy (Eden), Charlie & Shawanda (Declan & Stacy)
World's Greatest Dad
Buddy (Eden), Business Woman (Lexi), Jedidah & Henry (Flyer Guy 1 & 2),1st New Yorkers (Stacy, Madeline, Leah), Two New Yorkers (Declan & Alice), Passerby (Roxxi), Comforting New Yorker (Naomi), New Yorkers (Everyone)
Sparklejollytwinklejingley
Buddy (Eden) Jovie (Molly) Manager (Amelia) Macy’s Employee 1 (Madeline) Macy’s Employees (Everyone on stage from scene)
I'll Believe In You
Michelle (Sasha) & Emily (Claire)
World's Greatest Dad (Reprise)
Buddy (Eden), Carolers, Ensemble Carolers (Hunter, Alice, Vi, Sasha, Henry, Declan, Priya, Addie, Lexi, Stacy, Madeline, Emily, Olivia, Roxxi, Red, Lark, Hadley, Brialy, Naomi)
Never Fall in Love (With an Elf)
Jovie (Molly)
The Story of Buddy
Buddy (Eden), Mrs. Greenway (Ella), Walter (Calan), Deb (Mayleigh), Matthews (Georgie), Chadwick (Breesi), Sam (Jedidiah), Sarah (Leah), Michelle (Sasha), Emily (Claire)
Sparklejollytwinklejingley (Reprise)
ALL, Buddy (Eden), Jovie (Molly), Santa (Hunter), Walter (Calan), Emily (Claire), Michelle (Sasha), Charlotte Dennon (Roxxi), Mrs. Greenway (Ella), Chadwick (Breesi), Matthews (Georgie), Deb (Mayleigh), Manager (Amelia)
